• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Subscribe
  • Log In

Recrutes

Recrutes: Hockey scouting from a professional perspective from Grant McCagg and Habs coverage from a 33 year veteran covering the NHL from Brian Wilde.

  • Home
  • Habs Content
  • Rocket Content
  • Draft
    • 2023 NHL Draft Rankings
    • 2022 Recrutes NHL Draft Guide
    • Recrutes’ First Round NHL Draft Study
    • Draft News
    • Past Draft Guides
  • News & Notes
  • Video
  • Archives

Proudly Sponsored By

McLean’s Pub Call Of The Wilde: If I Were GM

January 8, 2018

By Brian Wilde

If I were GM of the Montreal Canadiens, I would make some bold moves. My philosophy would be based on what I watch nightly in a changing NHL. The game is all about speed now. The engine of that speed is not only mobile defencemen who pass the puck up quickly but also those defencemen must be able to join the rush to provide offence.

Those defencemen are the engine that makes the forwards run. As an example, Paul Byron is able to use his speed well this year but imagine how well he uses his speed if the defence could stretch out the opposition with quicker transition. So here’s what I do to take what the Habs have now and turn this around.

As anyone knows one of my favourite sayings is win the middle; win the game. The Habs haven’t been winning the middle for over 20 years now since Vincent Damphousse and Pierre Turgeon left. Unless they move the nets to the corner, you’re not winning with your best players as wingers. Check history to see champions led by centers like Crosby/Malkin Sakic/Forsberg Bergeron/Krejci Staal/Brind’Amour Lecavalier/Richards. In the last two decades, the champion has never been weak at center.

So this is my number one job, and I am going to be realistic here, I can’t just be pie in the sky and say here comes John Tavares. It’s not likely to happen even if I spend all I have. My trade piece to finally get better down the middle is Max Pacioretty. I don’t want Max on this team anymore. Not because I don’t like him but because I have to stop being a team whose best players are wingers. If I lose Max then I move Drouin to the wing. I have the same strength at wing with him as when I had Pacioretty there. Now I get this talented skilled player Drouin someone to play with.

Who?

My number one option is the first pick overall Ryan Nugent-Hopkins. He’s a complete 200 foot player with excellent offensive numbers this year. Pacioretty whose best days I fear are behind him would love to have the numbers of RNH this season. I can’t as GM pay Pacioretty for the diminished returns of seven years in front of him just because I loved the years behind him. I make this deal one for one and take the angry heat of my fan base initially until they watch my team with a better centerman. Down the line, my number two center is Ryan Poehling. My number three is Phillip Danault.

If I can’t swing Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, I like the potential of first rounder Robert Thomas. The Blues need top six scoring as they make a run for the first cup in their 51 year history. The Blues need Max. He could put them over the top this year.

Now I need to change the make up of my defence. I have one stud. He’s old school but he’s the best old school in the game with the best slap shot in the game. However, he’s the only defender of that kind I want. That’s right. I want my fast team to have defenders joining the rush. Watch Vegas and how they’re doing what they’re doing. That defence joins the rush all night every night. I don’t just want my defence pushing the puck up quickly. I want their entire bodies to push the puck up quickly right to the opposing goal.

This is going to sound a little revolutionary but the next phase in the NHL change is coming. It was only five years ago that the make-up of a team had fighters and defensive forwards. Now everyone must be talented. The next step in this evolution is every player must be able to “do it all” to some degree. The defenders must be able to help the attack. The attackers must be able to help the defence. If you can’t skate, you can’t play. If you’re a defender who can’t attack a little, you can’t play. If you’re an attacker who can’t defend a little, you can’t play.

Therefore, I have to take a real harsh cleansing bath of this defence I have constructed. I don’t want most of these players I have contracted. I need to lose Karl Alzner and I will give up a fourth rounder to do it. I didn’t say I will get a fourth rounder. I said I will also give you a fourth rounder. Just take him and that contract. He is not my vision.

I also have no use for Jordie Benn in my future. Benn used to be able to hold up a player with clutching or stick work but now they just fly right by him when he has to pivot and skate in the new NHL.

My defence is Weber, Mete, Petry, Juulsen, Schlemko, the first round pick I get which I hope will be Dahlin, Boqvist, Hughes, Dobson. Two years from now I have a beauty in Josh Brook coming, my second rounder of last year.

Up front, I get Nikita Scherbak up here to get acclimated. I let Jacob De La Rose play big minutes right now in Montreal in preparation for him to replace Plekanec.

In net, I have Carey Price and I pray he can stay healthy. I dangle Lindgren every day of the week trying to see what I can get for him. I don’t need him as a back-up. He’s too good. I need him to get me more talent because I am hovering around 25th in the league in goals for and goals against.

Oh, I also fire all of my assistant coaches except Waite. It’s not acceptable that I am bottom third in both power play and penalty kill. On the power play, I have a sniper in Galchenyuk. I have a wheel man in Drouin who quarterbacked the best power play in the league last year in Tampa. I have the best shot from the point in the league in Weber. How can I possibly be so bad with the extra man? These guys aren’t getting it done. That’s long enough time for them to show me how bad they are. Let’s see someone else try their hand now.

I don’t think all of these moves are particularly difficult or unrealistic.

This is my vision. It might seem as if I am in an ivory tower making it and if so my apologies. I sure don’t want to act like it isn’t hard. It is very hard, but this is what I would try to do.

About Brian Wilde

Brian Wilde has worked in hockey since he was 20. He was the rink side host for the Edmonton Oilers at CTV and Ottawa Senators for Sportsnet. He was also lead reporter on the Montreal Canadiens for 17 years at CTV Montreal.

View all posts by Brian Wilde

  • Richard McAdam says

    January 8, 2018 at 10:13 pm

    Have to agree with the coaching staff decision. I think all of us had really high hopes when Kirk Muller returned. Those hopes have not been realized. Daigneault should have been gone long ago.
    Who do these guys replaced with? Are there some solid up and comers who have been coaching this new up-tempo style in the juniors that are ready for their first taste of the NHL? An experienced hand who gets it? Please, I want it as much as anybody, but let’s not say Robinson. I don’t think he wants to give up his current gig—and he’s been ignored by the organization for so long already. There have to be better guys out there who are potential future head coaches that need a foot in the door to demonstrate that they can play guys in this new faster and more skilled NHL.
    Another name you mentioned the other day, Brian. Sam Bennett. He won’t get the opportunity to be a 1C with the Flames due to Monahan. Maybe he maxes out as a 2C. Would he be the guy here? Perhaps. He’s young and he’s got the skills package. Him and Drouin and Galchenyuk could probably make some magic together.

  • Sean Bower says

    January 8, 2018 at 10:29 pm

    Music to my ears Brian… shame those in charge don’t have the same forward thinking vision.

  • Angelo Palucci says

    January 8, 2018 at 10:31 pm

    I understand the want for RNH , as I think he can make a greater impact faster, but I also am really stoked at the idea of Max maybe getting Thomas plus something from St Louis as I think they are more desperate than the Oilers in terms of a SC run. I don’t know what that plus is.

    Curious, do you move Shaw if the offer is good? Seems he’d be a player type that a contender would want?

  • Joe Szyslak says

    January 8, 2018 at 10:35 pm

    I am on board with ALL of this. These are precisely the moves that need to be made. Excellent.

  • Darren Dembicki says

    January 8, 2018 at 10:41 pm

    You’re hired

  • Bill Shahidi says

    January 8, 2018 at 11:59 pm

    Alzner will be moved after more than ½ his salary gets paid after year 2. I disagree with trading Lindgren unless it’s part of a package to get a Tavares. Habs need a backup capable of potentially being a #1 with Price’s injury history. However I do think getting a top 2 centre for Pacioretty must be a priority. Even if they have to sweeten the deal. Maybe take another run at Draisaitl.

  • François Busque says

    January 9, 2018 at 12:16 am

    I would swing for the fences myself. Oilers are up against the cap, they have the opposite problem up front that the Habs but a weak defence. They need to spend smart money to upgrade that D, we have money to spend. I would offer Max (move Drouin to LW), Gallagher, Oilers really need that sandpaper, they have toughness but not a Gallagher type player who will force everyone on that team to work (recall Sherback to replace him) and a third piece TBD and would try to land Draisaitl (Oilers keep extra 2.5 million and RNH as 2C) and we take Lucic’s contract (Bergevin did make the same offer for him. Max and Gallagher’s salary will match Draisaitl next year plus Oilers have extra 6 million to spend. FYI, I don’t care what the 3rd piece is from AHL, Juniors, Europe or even NHL besides goalies and wingers. It can be De La Rose, Danault, a first rounder anything to try to land Draisaitl. RNH is plan B for me after I fail at Draisaitl (come on it’s a long shot but worth trying, don’t forget PC is the guy you who traded both Seguin and Hall so NOT impossible). As for Thomas, Roslovic etc would be my plan C if current NHLer is unachievable. Oh and I agree about firing all the coaches except Waite and Julien but I would tell Julien to coach like it’S 2018 not 2008 or else…

    What do you think about the swing for the fences approach?

  • Ralph Segreto says

    January 9, 2018 at 12:33 am

    Agree with almost all. All moves make sense. I’d also move Weber because a) he gets you a lot; b) his age doesn’t translate well to when the team is ready to contend. Are you ready to apply for the position, Brian?

    • Teri Madio says

      January 11, 2018 at 9:13 pm

      What about trading Weber? I know it would create a huge whole as we’d have no #1D. But what if u trade Weber to the Leads (r we handing them the cup?) but we get Nylander back to play 1C? Then in off season u look at a team with young solid D and trade Patches for a young top 2 dman?

      I live in TO so I see a lot of Leafs games. The kid can skate, pass, and score. Not sure why they have him on wing. He is 1 C on any team without Matthews on it.

      Draisitl in Edm would be incredible but would cost a lot more then Patches. Maybe a 1st, or 2nd, too? Or send a Dman that we keep his cap hit. He would cost a lot more then just Patches but i would listen and talk

  • Kilian Trotier says

    January 9, 2018 at 4:55 am

    Great one, Brian! As usual. Would love to get Thomas even a bit more than RNH. He’s not a proven NHLer, but you could build around him and Poeling and maybe draft quite high again next season that you definitely have a strong team in two years. But hey, RNH is really good, like really really good

  • Jennifer LaPoint says

    January 9, 2018 at 8:57 am

    The part I like most about this is firing the asst coaches! I honestly was surprised Julien kept them to begin with. I had really high hopes when Kirk Muller joined the team but he hasn’t improved anything on the power play like I expected. JJD I haven’t liked for a long time and think should be out. Waite is the best goalie coach in the league and should be given a lifetime contract with how he helped Carey fine tune his game and gets the best out of our backups. Changing coaching could have just as big an impact as any player trade because special teams are so important, and the habs get so few chances on the PP that we need to be able to get the most out of them!

  • Scott Murray says

    January 9, 2018 at 9:07 am

    Harsh medicine, and a lot of that depends on finding the right, agreeable dancing partner, but some good ideas there, Bryan.

  • Michael says

    January 9, 2018 at 9:59 am

    Brian, did you see the interview of Tortorella by Chris Cuthbert last night? Just some great quotes about how he wants he’s team to be focused defensively but keep a high level of offensive, speed, creativity…i just hope CJ will start to blend to two..or even them out a bit more.

    • Brian Wilde says

      January 9, 2018 at 10:32 am

      Agreed. But here’s my take. Julien is coaching an unbelievably dull style. The Habs are playing low event hockey with maybe 6 events a game trying to keep the chances low because he can’t play high event hockey and exchange lots of chances. My hope is a different roster will lead to higher event hockey. That’s my hope anyway. Because 5 years of this ? Dunno.

      Now I’m sorry if that seems negative but I watch a lot of other teams nightly and Montreal is probably the most old school team in the league.

      • Richard McAdam says

        January 9, 2018 at 2:47 pm

        The thing that’s weird is that occasionally they do play more of the up-tempo “high event hockey” and it can bring some success. The Vancouver 7-5 affair–while somewhat unstructured–was the most fun I’ve had this season watching a game. Last week’s 2-1 win over Tampa was another example of a game that had a lot of pace & intensity to it. The score didn’t really reflect how great a game it was with both sides shaking & baking.
        I know that it’s a risky proposition against some of the more high-octane teams in the NHL, but we know how good Carey Price is and can be–capable of stealing a win any night of the week lately. We may lose the occasional 4-2 game here or there, but against some of those teams we’re chasing or are in the pack with, at least it would inject some fun into a game between likely non-playoff teams. Gotta keep people coming through the turnstiles, after all.

  • Job Goulding says

    January 9, 2018 at 1:21 pm

    Think it would take more than a fourth rounder to get rid of alzner, hope i am wrong

    • Grant McCagg says

      January 9, 2018 at 3:34 pm

      Then don’t deal him if you actually pay to get rid of him. that’s not happening. He costs 1/18th of the cap space.. big deal.

  • michael Pelkonen says

    January 9, 2018 at 5:26 pm

    Great brian. I say number 1 get a president of hockey operations.molson blindly trusts bergy,he fd things up bigtime,yr 6 of a 5 yr rebuild and we wont make the playoffs. So we need a president.
    Said president fires bergy,julien,all asistant coachs
    Except wait. Bergy gets fired..its obvious,fd up markov,radulov resignings,excuses all the time,yr 6 of 5 yr rebuild wont make it to playoffs,unexceptable,GONE.
    Julien,nice guy,a pro,but the wrong style coach.this dinosaur D first coach wont change his stripes now.GONE. Hire patty roy as coach.
    Firesale alzner with a draftchoice,youpiies first born to go with him,just to wave byebye to grampa simpson alzner and his fat daddy deal.
    Plek can get us a draft pick for this june. Benn too.
    Trade cpt cherry picker tip in artist,mr.softy 67 for A mobile D.
    Trade price and his multi mega million deal before it kix in july1. (Who puts majority of caproom on a 30 yr ol goalie). Get a top C. Play lingren.

  • Halifaxhab says

    January 9, 2018 at 5:27 pm

    I love RNH. I love the piecesnon the blueline wr have that can skate. I would live to see new voices for special teams. But I would not hang my hat on Poehling becoming a top 6 any sooner than 4 years from now. So that would mean using that cap space. Perhaps to sign a Stastny maybe a Backlund. Someone who can be a realistic and effective place holder

  • peihab says

    January 9, 2018 at 5:59 pm

    Just not sure Poehling filled my expectations at Jr’s. Similar thoughts on De la Rose, just wish he had a little of Torrey Mitchell in him, that gave everything he had. Last assistant coach let go now coach of the year in Vegas

    • Grant McCagg says

      January 9, 2018 at 7:38 pm

      I’m not sure you should be expecting the world from an 18-year-old at his first WJC. Even Robert Thomas was ordinary after the first couple of games. Next year will be the litmus test for him.

      I also wouldn’t write off DLR. Fans need patience.

  • Mike says

    January 10, 2018 at 1:34 am

    Bergy cant sign players because of the diff in taxes,so how do you solve that? Simple overpay them.say eg: radulov gets 1.5 mill more in dallas after taxes,offer him 1.75 mill more to stay in mtl,then hes making .25 mill more then after tax $ of dallas,but you cant do that if ur paying ur goalie 10 mill a ssn for 8 yrs. so trade price for a top C ,play lingren.
    Hire julien brisebos as president,patty roy as coach,all new assistants.

  • Mark MarkK246 says

    January 10, 2018 at 1:14 pm

    You’re hired!!!

  • Dan Gordon says

    January 11, 2018 at 9:55 am

    Makes too much sense, management would never go for it. Mike McCarron in front of the net on the power play also makes sense. Love Weber (still miss Subban), but would move him if the right pieces came back. Price, Gallagher, Mete and Lehkonen are my only untouchables.

  • k3x says

    January 11, 2018 at 5:16 pm

    I am agreeing with you Brian. If only…

  • Mike Gudelj says

    January 11, 2018 at 5:51 pm

    Great article.Not totally sold on RNH Bur agree 100% with the assessment and plan for the defense.

  • Alex Pelletier says

    January 11, 2018 at 10:31 pm

    I totally agree with this Brian!

    In the end I think the crucial move will be the Pacioretty trade. Using him as a trade chip is looking like our best, and pretty much only hope of finally addressing our major weakness down the middle. This deal will make or break the franchise’s viability as a potential contender in the near and medium term. RNH would be a solid acquisition. I also really like Grant’s idea of Jack Roslovic if Winnipeg is willing to entertain it.

    On D like you mention I think it’s possible that it could be fixed internally over time with Mete, Juulsen, Brook, and then crucially whoever we get in the upcoming draft. And it looks like we must draft a defenseman now, unless we can trade the pick to a team looking for a forward, in return for a good young defenseman (a move Carolina might be willing to entertain).

    With Scherbak and maybe Evans coming next season, plus a potential top 5 pick in the draft, my feeling is that this team can actually be very, very competitive next season, since a few small changes can make a huge difference in this era of parity. But the crucial move is trading Pacioretty for a center, and I really hope Bergevin can make it happen, his job likely depends on it.

  • Gerry Salhani says

    January 12, 2018 at 8:35 am

    Brian for GM! I like your vision, and, how to get there! But u are in some cases, waiting for players, not yet on the roster. So this year is time to retool! Windows closing on some vet players, but, not closed for several years, Weber, CP, so still time to make it work! Plus speed, defence joining the rush, forwards joining the defence def the way to play right now! Let’s see where this goes! Hope MB reads ur stuff! Bet he does! Thanx Brian!

  • Stephen Lenet says

    January 14, 2018 at 12:03 am

    I hope that Geoff Molson is a Recruits subscriber.

  • Ioannis Segounis says

    January 14, 2018 at 11:02 am

    Excellent and these would be great moves. It is time to move on and address the big holes we have.

  • Primary Sidebar

    Recent Articles

    Jayden Joins Cayden in Laval

    Habs Prospects March 18 Points

    Habs Prospects March 16-17

    Oliver Bonk – Scouting Video

    Habs Prospects Points March 10-15

    InStat
    Please visit our sponsor!

    2022 Draft Guide

    Valley Snapshots

    Click Above To Order!

    Draft Prospect Profiles

    Search our directory of 2023 NHL Draft draft prospect profiles.

    Valley Snapshots

    Valley Snapshots

    Click Above To Order!
    • Home
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us

    Copyright © 2023 · Recrutes.ca. All rights reserved